Validity of different schedules of pain assessment during fentanyl TTS analgesia
|
Brunelli, Cinzia, National Cancer Institute of Milan, Italy, Caraceni, Augusto, National Cancer Institute of Milan, Italy, Martini, Cinzia, National Cancer Institute of Milan, Italy, Zecca, Ernesto, National Cancer Institute of Milan, Italy, Gorni, Giovanna, National Cancer Institute of Milan, Italy |
Aim of study was to evaluate if the subjective assessment of average pain over an 8-hour period is a valid estimate of pain intensity in cancer patients and whether it can accurately describe pain intensity during fentanyl TTS (f-TTS) analgesia. 44 consecutive patients with cancer pain treated with f-TTS (24 males and 20 females), recorded on 0-10 numerical scales the intensity of their pain at hourly intervals, the average of these 8 scores was then calculated (S1); at the 8th hour, they were requested to rate average pain intensity over the last 8 hours (S2). Cases who presented with hourly pain scores which were at least 2 points above S1, were classified as patients having pain peaks (PPP). Patients were also classified as TTS stable (TTS-S) if the same dose of f-TTS was used for more than three days or TTS unstable (TTS-U) if f-TTS dose had been changed within three days. Intraclass correlation coefficients between S1 and S2 was 0.85 (95% CI=0.77 - 0.93); 12 patients had pain peaks, but the comparison with others did not show any difference neither on S1 nor on S2 nor on the difference between them. Comparing TTS-S (18) with TTS-U (26) patients, average pain score (TTS-U mean - SD-3.5-1.5), TTS-S-3.2-1.8) and patientrated 8-hour average pain (TTS-U,=3.9-1.4, TTS-S,=3.2-1.5) did not show any difference, while more TTS unstable patients used at least one dose of p.r.n analgesics (61% vs 28% p-0.036). 38% of TTS unstable patients had pain peaks versus only 11% of TTS-S patients (p=0.08). The study shows that average pain over previous 8 hours is a valid estimate of pain intensity and gives an fair description of fentanyl TTS (f-TTS) analgesia even if hourly measurement gives a more sensitive measure of not completely stable pain.
|